Home ENGLISH VERSION Role of protozoa in development of Chronic Periodontitis: clinical aspect of Trichosoma...

Role of protozoa in development of Chronic Periodontitis: clinical aspect of Trichosoma Tenax and Entamoeba Gingivalis findings in oral microbioma.


Role of protozoa in development of Chronic Periodontitis: clinical aspect of Trichosoma Tenax and Entamoeba Gingivalis findings in oral microbioma.

Role of protozoa in development of Chronic Periodontitis: clinical aspect of Trichosoma Tenax and Entamoeba Gingivalis findings in oral microbioma.

1) Overview/intro

Periodontal disease is a complex inflammation/immune-mediated compromission of connective and epithelial tissues in dental periodontal ligament. Serving as a stabilizing and mechanical absorption system, periodontal ligament consist in a complex and organized structure presenting a really delicate balance with oral microbioma and immunomediated alterations.

Approximately 5 to 20 percent of the worlds population suffers from severe generalized periodontitis. Immuno-modulation, alteration in oral bacterial population and its related inflammation damage are clearly involved in the etiology. Despite this fundamental knowledge, a large amount of real pathways of this multi-factorial disease are still unclear. Periodontal lesions contain numerous neutrophils, motile bacteria, spirillae, spinning rods, and protozoa, multicellular highly pathogenic organisms.

Nevertheless, there is accumulated evidence that periodontal diseases mainly develope in permissive hosts, who have local dysimmunity. Despite the fact that more experiments are needed, it can be hypothesized that one or several events may upset the balance of host– microbiome homoeostasis. A local dysimmunity may favour the development, selection and pathogenicity expression of periopathogens (including bacteria and protists), leading to a shift from ‘eubiosis’ to ‘dysbiosis’.

Recent literature findings, estimate and subsequently strongly confirmed an evaluable linkage between oral periodontal lesions and systemic inflammation. This largely accepted relationship provides a remarkable knowledge necessity of every aspect in etio pathogenesis.

Periodontal alteration was been often considered a microbial mediated disease.

A large number of microbiological assays has been developed to understand, prevent and even stabilize an advanced disease form.

Specific protozoic organism, usually not triggered in conventional microbiological assays, could not be evaluated and underestimated by the clinician. Their role, pathogenetic mechanism and agonist activity is far to be completely known. As a matter of fact, protozoic organism are still possibly involved in determination of chronical periodontitis and their knowledge is essential for a comprehensive overview in microbioma-mediated oral and gingival alteration.

A possibile parasites pathogenetical pathway must be discussed and investigated due to their habitual oral commensal finding. These pathogen organism must be clearly and carefully identified and evaluated for a possible anthagonistic spontaneous conversion. These conditions could be largely observed in unbalanced oral microbiome and patient with poor oral hygiene.

2) Protozoa: pathogenetic mechanism and body response

The possible role of parasites in the development of periodontitis and oral tissue damages has been poorly studied. The impact of parasites in periodontium pathophysiology is still debated and little information are available regarding the conditions favourable for their occurrence. Reported clinical cases includes a large number of lesion mediated by commensal parasites organism usually located in oral and oro-pharyngeal areas.

In a general view, parasites present a complex and sofisticated pathogenetic mechanism. Parasitic infections present hard diagnosis, high chronicity, typical inflammation symptoms (fever, astenia, weakness, chronical fatigue, abscessual and purulent lesions, tumor, dolor, rubor, calor and functio laesa localized in specific areas). Despite this, parasitic organism present highly complex hiding mechanism and classical systemical immunomediated recognizing and antigenes elimination systems are often unsuccesful.

Global parasitic pathogenetic mechanism is mediated by various aspect:

-Target system/organ damages: Parasitic organisms are largely known for their often expressed organ-related pathogenicity (trophism). Direct damages are usually mediated by progressive tissue direct elimination, blood vessels damages, direct hemorragia, nervous alteration and organ specific damages. A tissue degradation is often silent and could be understimated by patient and clinician.

-Immunomodulated damage: parasites surface antigenes leads to a inflammation bacterial derived response model.

A large amount of immuno modulator are functionally called to attend in antigene presentation. Interleukin and Cytokines are often reported to take a role, enphatizing the inflammation process and consequential chronicity.

– Supplies decreasing: Parasitic organisms often challenge with host for nutrition and life supplies. Thus compromising ideal and regular systemical and local functions.

3) Clinical analysys of protozoa mediated periodontal diseases:

It has been shown that protozoa can both induce tissue damage and benefit from modified micro-environement.

Parasites may evolved to grow and exacerbate the injuries strategies by genotype changes in oral cavity. Parasitic periodontal diseases often occurs in tandem with bacterial alterations caused by an imbalance of the bacterial flora leading to a real opportunistic colonization . Recent studies have emphasized the ability of parasites to induce changes in some features of microbial communities.

Opportunistic parasitic infections involves either man or woman aged in 40-50 yy range with, debilitation, compromised systemical health, compromised immune system or immunodeficiency.

Along with inflammation and the deepening of the periodontal pockets, the periodontal environement becomes more anaerobic, resulting in a bacterial shift from a Gram+ positive to a Gram-negative flora. This decrease in the partial pressure in oxygen may explain why the depth of periodontal pocket may be a critical factor for the anaerobic parasites colonization and growth.

3.1) Trichosoma Tenax and Entamoeba gingivalis: role in periodontal pathogenetic pathways.

Trichomonas Tenax and Entamoeba gingivalis are largely reported as oral commensal. These pathogenic organism were reported to be often related to periodontal disease and gum alterations and their identification in host tissues is often related to oral hygiene, global and immunal patient health, geographical factors and QOL (quality of life) status. This comprising water consumption, environmental pollution and water filtering systems.

Among the parasites found in dental plaque, Trichomonas tenax, an anaerobic motile-flagellated protozoan, may play a role in the pathophysiology of periodontal diseases. This 12–20 μm long and 5–6 μm wide organism is either ellipsoidal or ovoid in shape and has four anterior flagella of unequal lengths. Trichomonas tenax is a protozoan classified in the same genus as Trichomonas vaginalis .

Entamoeba gingivalis (E. gingivalis) is found in the oropharynx, but rarely in the head and neck lesions. This microorganism is commonly found in patients with poor dental health and oral hygiene, periodontal disease and immune suppression. It was the first commensal found in the human oral cavity.

  1. gingivalis can be usally observed on the surface of the teeth and gum tissues.

Inflammatory process produces a propitious anaerobic environment for parasites growth.

Pathogenic bacteria involved in periodontal host colonization and immune subversion use complement and toll-like receptor (TLR) bacteria –like signalling pathways. Parasites are recognized by TLR. Stimulation of the innate immune system via TLR4 by T. vaginalis has been reported. Similar mechanism within the periodontium was also hypothesized for T. tenax. Massive neutrophil recruitment found in human periodontitis can be explained by observation of patients infected by T. vaginalis in which a similar developement of a predominant tissue recruitment of neutrophils can be identificated.

Moreover, these pathogens produce fibronectin-like proteins, responsible for tissue adhesion. Given this pathogenic property, host tissue disruption and lysis may be induced by T. tenax secretion of peptidases such as cathepsin B-like proteinases for matricial type 1 collagen and gelatin hydrolyses or haemolysins for erythrolysis. Recently Ribeiro et al. confirmed the ability of the flagella to adhere to periodontal epithelial cells. After only 6 h, T. tenax in co-culture caused significant direct damage, disrupting some of the cells in the tissue, inducing membrane damage and cell apoptosis. In contrast, T. vaginalis has been found in the oral cavity but failed to elicit in vitro damage on periodontal cells.

3.2) Clinical overview

Clinical evaluation and diagnosis of parasitic periodontitis may result difficult. A large number per year of parasites mediated periodontal diseases remain undiagnosed due to a real lack of recognizable distinction and pathognomonic signs.
These types of periodontal disease can shown evaluable signs of a common aggressive periodontitis, a fast and unstoppable progressive damage of eptihelial tissues and connective structure of periodontal ligament. Suppuration, oedema, hyperemia, erithema and lack of pain can possibily associate to these general signs.

A fast progression of damages, apical migration of gingival free margin and adherent mucosa as well as the delection of primary gingival cervical groove, can possibly be signs of parasitic progression, in absence of any primary systemical illness. Absence in specific pathogenic bacterial complex after microbiological assays can be possibly associated. This interpretation must be conducted carefully due to parasites’ natural agohonistic activity that rises specific pathogens presence.

Due to its fast immuno mediated modulation and fast flogosis progression, a bone resorbtion can be osberved in vertical dimension and may be consensual to a dramatic tissue apical migration.

In patient with low oral hygiene adherence, presence of parasites can be globalized and substain, exacerbate or amplificate flogosis, diapedesis of Interleukin, TNF and immuno modulation factors. As it starts as an aggressive disease, a parasitic periodontal disease could progress and become chronic. As they can’t be processed as bacterial pathogens, parasites migrates in various sector, rising inflammation and bacterial opportunistic proliferation. With these conditions, real causes of chronical periodontitis could be undiscovered and every clinical management may result uneffective or harmful.

Furthermore T.Tenax and E. Gingivalis can shown peculiar and specific pathogenic activities with direct effect on connective and epithelial tissues in periodontal ligament.

4) Oral Myasis

Oral Myasis is a rare parasitic infection supported by Diptera larvae. While systemic myasis is often hided and sneaky, oral infections could lead in local alterations commonly compatible with periodontal abscess or damages.
Kumar et al. in 2012 reported over 10 Muscidaes species responsible for oral myasis. Starting as a common abscess, it may involves periodontal ligaments, adherent and alveolar mucosa. It is associated with poor oral hygiene, alcoholism, senility, suppurating lesion, severe halitosis, and other ambient/economical conditions.

Alterations may occurs in alveolar bone, leading to fracture, larvae exposition, dental mobility. Myasis could be evident and more evaluable than parasitic sub infections and their diagnosis could be realized with objective examination and radiographic analysis. OM is quite similar in aetiopathogenetical mechanism to parasitic infections (cytokines/interleukine diapedesis, leukocyte extravasation, vascular enlargement, aspecific immunity) but is a quite rare clinical condition.

5) Clinical Management

Due to its predominantly silent progression, therapeutical aspect of parasitic periodontal disease may be complex and very different. Most cases may remain undiagnosed or not clearly identified. A resistence to chemo antimicrobial therapy was often considered as a common aspect between many kind of parasitic induced periodontal disease.

Immunal response, systemical health and pharmacotherapy should be considered in every therapy.

Clinical management begins with parasitic evaluation. A concern in literature reports was the method of parasite identification. The method most frequently used was direct microscopy, with or without staining (e.g. Giemsa). This method is time consuming and insufficient to discriminate parasite species, because T. tenax is morphologically close to T. vaginalis. Molecular methods are also been reported to be effective methods for Entamoeba gingivalis and Trichomonas Tenax identification but more studies are needed to clearly understand incindence and prevalence of false positive/negative. In vitro culture is still largely used to really declarate a valid diagnosis.

Mechanical causal therapy has been largely described in literature reviews and RCT. Non-surgical periodontal therapy (NSPT) was succesfully described by Maybody et al. In 2016. A Primary Goal in NSPT could be a quantitative decreasing of parasitic species, facilitating their non aggressive/commensal re-conversion.

After clinical diagnosis of moderate and severe non responsive periodontitis, patient in both sex were enrolled and underwent to plaque and saliva sample collection. Giemsa coloration was performed for T. Tenax and E. Gingivalis identification. An ultrasonic scaler treatment was performed after CAL and PPD detection including charting.

The frequency of Entamoeba gingivalis was reduced in saliva (p= 0.007) and plaque (p= 0.027) three weeks after the treatment. Likewise, the frequency of Trichomonas tenax reduced in saliva (p= 0.030); however, the decrease was not significant in plaque (p= 0.913).

Results shown moderate statistical evidence supporting the efficacy of stand alone NSPT in performing complete T. Tenax and E. Gingivalis reduction.

Oral trichomonas are sensitive to anti-parasitic treatment. Zvetkova et al. In 1988 investigated the clinical improvement and the titration of antibodies after anti-parasitic treatment with tinidazole in patients infected by oral trichomonads. After 3 days of treatment, oral clinical signs had disappeared, and titration of antibodies was normalized by months 6–12 after treatment. Tinidazole is also efficient against anaerobic bacteria involved in periodontal disease as described by Alou et al. in 2009.

Evidence shown that both pharmacological and NSPT stand alone performed therapies were not considered effective. A dinamic-aghonistic duo should be considered in T.Tenax – E. Gingivalis related periodontal infection treatment .
However, additional studies are needed to support this critical relationship.

A possible efficacy of probiotic enzime linked therapy, should be considered due to its microbiome balancing capabilites. This could lead in a non-pathogenical devolution of parasitic species after repopulation of antagonist bacterial species. An adequate number of patient should be enrolled in RCT designed studies.

Patient with diagnosed parasitic oral infections, should be adequately monitorized. A punctual and precise recall plan must be always designed. First control is reported to be effective and usually hypotizable within 30 days after a primarly mechanical treatment. In a practical therapeutical point of view, Diagnosis and therapy of any form of periodontal disease should always respect largely used and approved protocol, regardless to the inborn activity or the specie of a single pathogen. Oral cavity must be considered as a balanced environment and pathogen population as a single unit entity with dynamic linkage to every other system.

7) Conclusions

Comprension of parasites pathogenic mechanism is essential for comprehesive understanding of periodontal disease.

Aggressive initial form of PD and subsequent chronic manifestation are common signs of microbiomal changes in oral flora but a non responsive disease to common used therapy should alert clinicians. Hypothesis of parasitic infection should be adequately analized with common first level diagnosis assays. Use of probiotic, anti-parasitic therapy associated with mechanical hygiene therapy is reported to be effective and an eligible therapy for parasites mediated periodontal disease.

Due to their common presence in oral microbiome, parasites should be known by the modern dental clinicial and their role in periodontitis pathogenic mechanism should be adequately analized in future RCTs.

8) Reference

 Arslan S, Islamoğlu A, Çobanoğlu B. A rare case of gingival myiasis in a 2-year-old child. Int J Paediatr Dent. 2013;23(5):387-388.

  1. Aydenizöz M, Dik B. [A case of gingival myiasis in a lamb caused by the Wohlfahrtia magnifica (Diptera: Sarcophagidae)]. Turkiye Parazitol Derg. 2008;32(1):79-81.
  2. Bonner M, Amard V, Bar-Pinatel C, et al. Detection of the amoeba Entamoeba gingivalis in periodontal pockets. Parasite. 2014;21:30.
  3. Çetın Özdemır E, Ekşi F, Şenyurt SZ, Üstün K, Karaoğlan İ, Ercıyas K. [A case of gingival myiasis caused by Wohlfahrtia magnifica]. Mikrobiyol Bul. 2014;48(3):512-517.
  4. Droma EB, Wilamowski A, Schnur H, Yarom N, Scheuer E, Schwartz E. Oral myiasis: a case report and literature review. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2007;103(1):92-96.
  5. Ghabanchi J, Zibaei M, Afkar MD, Sarbazie AH. Prevalence of oral Entamoeba gingivalis and Trichomonas tenax in patients with periodontal disease and healthy population in Shiraz, southern Iran. Indian J Dent Res. 2010;21(1):89-91.
  6. Marty M, Lemaitre M, Kémoun P, Morrier JJ, Monsarrat P. Trichomonas tenax and periodontal diseases: a concise review. Parasitology. 2017;144(11):1417-1425.
  7. Mehr AK, Zarandi A, Anush K. Prevalence of Oral Trichomonas tenax in Periodontal Lesions of Down Syndrome in Tabriz, Iran. J Clin Diagn Res. 2015;9(7):ZC88-90.
  8. Rashidi Maybodi F, Haerian Ardakani A, Fattahi Bafghi A, Zafarbakhsh A. The Effect of Nonsurgical Periodontal Therapy on Trichomonas Tenax and Entamoeba Gingivalis in Patients with Chronic Periodontitis. J Dent (Shiraz). 2016;17(3):171-176.
  9. Rashidi Maybodi F, Haerian Ardakani A, Fattahi Bafghi A, Zafarbakhsh A. The Effect of Nonsurgical Periodontal Therapy on Trichomonas Tenax and Entamoeba Gingivalis in Patients with Chronic Periodontitis. J Dent (Shiraz). 2016;17(3):171-176.
  10. Tang H, Wang XW, Tang GH. [Two cases with gum myiasis caused by Wohlfahrtia magnifica]. Zhongguo Ji Sheng Chong Xue Yu Ji Sheng Chong Bing Za Zhi. 2003;21(1):30.
  11. Suleyman Y, Ulfet C, Berna H, Arzu A, Yıldıray Ş , Cağrı E, Melike K. Investigation of Entamoeba gingivalis and Trichomonas tenax in Periodontitis or Gingivitis Patients in Kayseri. Turkiye Parazitol Derg. 2016; 40: 17-21). Turkish Society for Parasitology – Available online at www.tparazitolderg.org 2015